About this blog Subscribe to this blog

Flag Football and Title IX

Five thousand girls in Florida play flag football in high school as a school-sponsored sport.  It’s the fastest growing high school sport in the state.

The interest is so high that some schools field teams at the freshman, junior, and varsity levels and still make cuts.  The sport is cheap and girls who never considered themselves particularly athletic are trying out and having fun.

So what’s the problem?  The sport began about 10 years ago when the Florida legislature required schools to keep records of student participation by gender to comply with Title IX.  As a result, schools adopted flag football and competitive cheerleading for girls. Flag football  

Advocates for equal sports opportunities for girls argue that flag football is a dead-end sport.  In other words, there are no college teams or professional teams.  All high school sports for boys have opportunities beyond high school. 

But what are those opportunities?  Over a million high school boys play football.  Only 5000 scholarships are offered at Division I schools.   About 430,000 girls play high school basketball, including 130,000 seniors.  Only 32 (3.3%) played at NCAA schools, and only 1% of those players were drafted by the pros.

So from a purist standpoint, yeah, flag football isn’t an NCAA sport.  But some girls who play it do play other sports, and one of the things girls say they like about flag football is that you can’t get a scholarship in it – so the pressure is off.

On the other hand, considering competitive cheerleading as a “sport” is another thing entirely.  Why would you cheer for someone else when you could be playing the game yourself?  Even if it's flag football?

Comments

To be fair, most competitive cheerleaders rarely cheer for someone else. Many schools field multiple cheer teams: those that cheer on the football, basketball, soccer, and/or wrestling teams, and those that compete. Some girls may enjoy the game aspect, and other may enjoy the competitive aspect. Some love both and join both teams!

Competitive cheer is just that - competitive. Teams attend competitions, sometimes every weekend, around the state and country. The point is to demonstrate motion, voice, dance, tumbling, and stunting skills, and the teams are scored by judges, much like in gymnastics.

A statement like, "Why would you cheer for someone else when you could be playing the game yourself?" is unfair to competitive cheerleaders who put in the time and effort to perfect their skills and win. Consider checking out http://www.varsity.com to see what competitive cheer is really like these days! Certainly, if not a sport, these girls are athletic competitors with a right to be recognized.

Looks like a fun event! We should encourage the younger generation to get active again under the sun instead of online.

I think girls should but not with boys they should have there own group!

Post Comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Advertisement

Advertisement

Categories

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in Practical Leadership are strictly those of the author and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Scholastic, Inc.