While hybrid projectors that don’t require periodic lamp changes have the power to save several hundreds of dollars a year, they have been expensive. That is until now, with the announcement of Casio’s $700 XJ-V1 projector. It may be priced a couple hundred dollars higher than a traditional classroom projector, but its hybrid laser and LED illumination engine is rated to last for 20,000 hours (and is guaranteed for five years or 10,000 hours of use) and doesn’t contain any mercury. That can save a couple hundred dollars a year in replacement lamps you don’t need to buy and install while cutting electricity use nearly in half. Small and light, the XJ-V1 puts out 2,700 lumens in XGA resolution and has VGA, HDMI as well as audio connections.
Want a $2,000 Casio XJ-UT310WN short throw projector for free? Casio is giving 50 of them away, one for a school in each state. The contest will give the projectors to the students (actually their schools) who write the best essays on the dangers of mercury poisoning and how to reduce it in the environment. The tie-in is that the company’s projectors use LEDs and Lasers to illuminate the image and don’t have any mercury. Casio has put together a nice video that explains the dangers of mercury and how to enter the contest. Entries for the Casio Education Grant Contest will be judged on knowledge of the science of mercury, creativity and originality. The best part is that the general public gets to vote on their favorite entries.
Since the appearance of the first interactive panels for overhead projectors 25 years ago, one thing has been a constant when it comes to teaching with a projector: the video cable. No more, as Epson is the first to integrate two popular wireless AV protocols into the PowerLite 1985WU for wireless projection from anywhere in the room.
It may sound like magic, but the PL1985WU can put everything from an English lesson on sentences to a math video about triangles on-screen without a cable in sight. It doesn’t matter if the system uses WiDi (notebooks and PC tablets) or Miracast (tablets and phones), the PL1985WU can handle both. It works by directly moving the data to the projector. In other words, there’s no adapter or connection box needed.
Setting the projector up is the easy part because at about 10-pounds, the PL1985WU is light enough to lug around and install without an assistant. Its case is white with black trim and has a slide open lens cover that blanks the screen while it’s closed. There’s an adjustable front foot as well and ones at the back corners for setting it up on a table as well as three mounting points underneath for attaching it to the ceiling.
It has keystone correction for horizontal (up to 20-degrees) and vertical (up to 30-degrees) distortion so the projector doesn’t have to be installed dead center. The projector,though, lacks the ability to shift the image slightly up-down or right-left to fine-tune its position. There is a helpful bull’s eye pattern built into the PL 1985WU that can streamline aiming and focusing the projector.
Inside, the projector has three 1,920 by 1,200 resolution LCD panels for the primary colors and a traditional high-pressure lamp that can create up to a 25-foot image. Rated at 4,800 lumens of brightness, the projector has a wide 1.6:1 optical zoom ratio. There’s no comparison to an XGA or wide-XGA projector with the PL 1985WU having less jaggedness, more consistent color and less pixilation.
It has the bonus of Faroudja’s DCDi digital video processor chip built-in. Usually reserved for theatrical projectors costing many times more than the PL1985WU, the processor can reduce flicker and interlacing artifacts that are common with classroom projectors while sharpening edges.
After decades of relying on cables, the easiest way to deliver the class’s work with the PL 1985WU is to do it wirelessly. You’ll need to set the projector’s networking configuration to screen mirroring, instead of a LAN connection and it takes about 30 seconds to put the laptop’s little screen onto the PL 1985WU’s big screen. After that, the projector mirrors what’s on the computer’s screen and all sound is transferred. The projector had a wireless range of 45-feet, plenty for all but the largest classroom or lecture hall.
As good and easy as it is, the wireless abilities of the PL 1985WU aren’t perfect. The setup ignores Google’s Chromecast, Apple TV as well as Samsung’s ScreenCast. Alternatively, you can use Epson’s iProjection Android and iPad apps to project material, but it’s limited to images, saved video and Web pages, not live screen mirroring.
Of course, you can connect the old fashioned way because the projector has two HDMI ports, one of which can work with MHL-based phones and tablets. There’s a composite video port and a pair of VGA inputs as well as one for mirroring the projector’s output. It adds an RS-232 for controlling the projector remotely.
The PL 1985WU has three separate audio inputs and an output jack as well as USB connectors. Next to the ports is a 16-watt speaker that is plenty for the typical classroom, but it wouldn’t work with a microphone. In addition to displaying material from a USB memory key, the projector can connect with both wired and wireless LANs, something that’s usually an option.
The projector’s remote control is small and light, but lacks the laser pointer of BenQ’s HC1200. In its place is the choice of three different digital pointers.
You can have the PL 1985WU run through its inputs looking for a signal, change the aspect ratio and mute the audio while blanking the screen. The remote control adds something that is a luxury in classroom projectors: the ability to put two inputs on-screen side by side in split format. There are several size combinations, but not all port combinations work.
In addition to ten different color temperature settings, the projector has 7 modes to choose from for working with traditional screens, black- or whiteboards or even faithfully display x-rays with a Dicom Sim setting. The Dynamic setting is brightest but makes everything look bluish-green, while the Presentation has some of the whitest and brightest whites of any projector and the Theater setting produces much warmer images.
All told, in Dynamic mode, the projector put out 5,715 lumens of light, nearly 20 percent above its 4,800 lumen spec. If you use the more realistic sRBG setting, that drops to about 3,800 lumens, or more than enough to teach in just about any classroom with the lights on and the shades up. In fact, the PL 1985WU delivers so much light to the screen, it could be in contention for use in a small auditorium.
A slow starter, the projector took 38 seconds to start up and about a minute to get to full brightness. It can shut itself off in 1.3-seconds. Its fan is a little loud at 46.2dBi at 36-inches.
At full blast, the PL 1985WU uses 380-watts of power, but not a watt when it’s off. You can use the projector’s Eco mode to reduce its brightness and cut its power use, but I think most will use the PL 1985WU flat out for its exceptional brightness. Expect the projector to have annual operating expenses of $153 if you factor in the $150 lamp (that’s rated to last for 3,000 hours) and electricity at 12 cents per kilowatt hour. That’s less than half the expenses to run BenQ’s high definition HC1200 projector that puts out one-third less light.
The two-year warranty includes next-day replacement, but at $1,700 the PL 1985WU’s only major drawback is that its price is several hundred dollars over the price of the BenQ HC1200 and about double what the typical classroom projector sells for. Epson’s PowerLite 1980WU model does without the Miracast/WiDi feature and puts out 400 less lumens for $500 less.
But, that would mean that schools would miss out on the PL 1985WU’s greatest ability: to make video cables obsolete.
Epson PowerLite 1985WU
+ Stunning HD image
+ Very bright
+ Miracast and WiDi wireless
+ Built-in video processor
+ iProjection tablet apps
+ Picture in picture mode
- No Apple TV, or Chromecast
Instead of struggling with balancing a notebook or tablet on a ladder to put out images for checking and optimizing a projector’s output, I have a great alternative that I will never again do without. My secret weapon is StarTech’s HDMI/DVI Video Test Pattern Signal Generator. The $300 handheld device is the best investment you can make toward making sure every projector is up to snuff.
The key is that the HDMI pattern generator can output eight different standard images for making sure that the projector is centered, focused and is delivering the best color balance it is capable of. It can’t match the 32 patterns that the $600 Kramer 850 can deliver or some of the more intricate patterns, like the Guilloche or even a SMPTE TV test pattern. Still, it should be plenty for most set ups.
In addition to a grid pattern that’s perfect for making sure everything is square, level and sharply focused, the generator has a grid with colored intersections and a standard white and black checkerboard image. The device can also deliver patterns with grayscale and color bars as well as ramps for tweaking its output.
Not all the images are static, though. The StarTech pattern generator has a sequential routine in which the colors in four quadrants rotate clockwise as well as a series of full field images that roll through red, green and blue screens. About the only thing it lacks is a full field white image that can be used for finding hotspots, measuring brightness and adjusting the projector’s color temperature.
As far as its physicality goes, the device is 1.1- by 5.2- by 3.4-inches, weighs just 5 ounces and can fit into a shirt pocket. Unlike the Kramer 850 and many other pattern generators, the StarTech device is portable and can be powered by a disposable 9-volt battery or the included AC adapter. A fresh battery lasted for over 4 hours and of continuous use and an LED blinks when its power is running low.
The best part is that you don’t need a degree in electrical engineering to get the most out of it because it’s simple to operate. In addition to an on-off switch and buttons for cycling through the patterns, the device has a key for changing the resolution and color depth of the output. The pattern generator can be used in a variety of resolutions and color depths, including 1080p at 8-, 10- or 12-bit, 720p at 8- or 10-bit and VGA at 8-bit.
The HDMI output port, uses the version 1.3 spec and will work with up to a 16.4-foot cable and will even tell you of an HDCP error. With older projectors you can use a DVI or VGA adapter.
While the emphasis is on the visuals, the pattern generator can help with audio as well. It puts out a steady 1 kilohertz tone for testing and tweaking a projector’s sound system. On the downside, it lacks a volume control, mute button or a way to adjust the frequency of the test tone.
It took 6.7-seconds for the pattern generator to put an image on-screen, faster than just about any computer can start up and display a stored image. It’s the perfect gadget for everything from a projector’s initial set up to making sure that every display is creating the best images it can. It also removes the problem of different laptops handling color differently when adjusting projectors or displays.
At $300 (with a 2-year warranty) it’s one of the least expensive pattern generators on the market, rivaling those that cost several times more, but lacks a preview screen. In fact, it’s inexpensive enough to be the standard for setting up every projector and display in a school, guaranteeing that they are all doing their best.
+ 8 patterns
+ Three different resolutions and color depths
+ Audio tone
+ Battery or AC operation
- Lacks white image
- No volume control
Whoever it was who said that schools don’t need high-definition projectors couldn’t have been more wrong. In fact, the sharper the images, the better the content and the better focus students have on the lesson. At about $1,000, BenQ’s HC1200 makes HD cheap enough for classrooms.
The HC1200 is a one of a kind projector, at least for the moment. At 4.4- by 14.2- by 10.2-inches, its gray and black case doesn’t stand out from the crowd, but it’s what’s inside that counts. The projector has a single digital light processing (DLP) imaging chip coupled with a traditional high-pressure lamp that combine to put out 1,920 by 1,080 images at a rated 2,800 lumens of brightness.
Thanks to come clever engineering with the projector’s color wheel, optics and light source, the HC1200 sets a new standard for color fidelity that no other projector in its category can match. It can deliver over 1 billion individual colors and covers the entire sRGB color gamut.
It may lack optional lenses for different locales, but the single lens approach not only makes the HC1200 very economical, but the lens it uses is well suited to the classroom. It has a wide 1.5:1 optical zoom ratio, can fill a 6-foot screen from about 7-feet away and tops out at a 25 foot image. It comes with a tethered lens cap, but it can be hard to get your fingers in far enough to fine-tune the focus.
In addition to projecting 3-D material, the HC1200 offers three teaching templates that include blanks for penmanship, a lined screen or a blank image divided into quadrants. It lacks the ability to use interactive pens, though.
The HC1200 has one of the best assortments of input ports with a pair of VGA, composite- and S-video as well as two HDMI connectors. It adds a wired LAN plug but to connect with a wireless network, you’ll need BenQ’s $50 WiFi adapter. The system adds VGA-out port for mirroring the content as well as RS-232, USB, audio and the projector is compatible with Crestron’s and AMX’s control software.
For schools with powered screens, the HC1200 has the bonus of a 12-volt trigger button for opening and closing the screen. While most of BenQ’s competitors cut corners on their remote controls, the HC 1200’s remote not only mimics the projector’s control panel, but provides instant access to networking settings. There’s a laser pointer built-in, a luxury that every classroom should have.
Rather than the expected rectangular box, the HC1200 is shaped like a trapezoidal prism that’s larger on the top than the bottom. It has an adjustable front leg, four attachment points underneath for ceiling mounting and at about 8-pounds it is easy from one person to install it. The HC1200 comes with a padded bag for those who want to store or move it from room to room.
It might be a fast starter with the ability to put an image on the screen in 23 seconds, but it takes upwards of a minute to cool down and shut itself off when the class is done. It’s also a little on the loud side with its exhaust fan putting out 44.8 decibels 3-feet from the projector.
The HC1200 has the expected vertical keystone correction, but lacks horizontal keystone correction and image shifting. Its built-in grid test pattern can help streamline getting the projector’s picture just right and its focus was spot-on from edge to edge. There’s a hot spot at the bottom, but you can hardly notice it.
In addition to three color temperature settings, the HC1200 has four projection modes and the ability to project onto different colored walls. While its Dynamic setting is very bright, it has a lot of green in it and Presentation has over-saturated colors, Cinema has a warm feel. Overall, the sRGB setting offers the best balance between brightness and color fidelity. You can also set up two user-defined modes with presets of your own choosing.
The HC1200 can put 2,894 lumens on the screen in Dynamic mode, just above its rating. Using the system’s EcoSmart setting, the projector delivers 10-percent lower brightness, but reduces the HC1200’s power draw from 375- to 315-watts.
The projector doesn’t require a dust filter, so maintenance is a snap and the projector’s optics have been designed so that its colors don’t fade over time. Its $350 replacement lamp is rated to last 2,000 hours and can be swapped in about two minutes. It adds up to estimated annual costs of $352 if it’s used for 8 hours every school day and electricity costs the national average of 12 cents per kilowatt-hour. This is high compared to other projectors with lower resolution, but not to HD devices.
At around $1,000 the HC 1200 sets a new standard for projectors at roughly 50-percent less than comparable devices, removing all the excuses for not getting HD projectors. It not only leads in color fidelity and resolution in the classroom, but upfront costs as well.
+ Excellent color fidelity
+ Wide optical zoom lens
+ Laser pointer
- Lacks image shift and horizontal keystone correction
- High operational costs
If it’s Epson, the bottom line on classroom projectors looks like it’s settling in on $340. That’s the price of the new PowerLite S27, an SVGA projector that might cut a few corners but has the best price tag today. It uses three LCD panels and a traditional high-pressure lamp to put 2,700 lumens on the classroom screen while including such luxuries as horizontal keystone correction, optional WiFi connections and compatibility with Epson’s iProjection app for working from a tablet or phone. If you’re looking for XGA resolution, the PowerLite X27 does the trick for $100 more.
The latest in projectors are ones that don’t have expensive lamps that need replacing, but are powered by LEDs and lasers, like Casio’s EcoLite XJ-V1. The projector puts out 2,700 lumens and its solid state lighting element has been rated to last 20,000 hours of use, or more than a decade of typical use. A big bonus is that it uses only 180 watts, making it an efficient way to light up a lesson.
With all the digital projectors around, you’d think that the overhead projector and its transparent plastic sheets are dead. You’d be very wrong, because Apollo’s projectors are cheaper and less expensive to use. For instance, the Horizon 2 model (photo, right) has a double Fresnel lens for sharp detail, a 10- by 10-inch stage and puts out 2,000 lumens. The projector’s $175 price tag blows away all digital projectors. Meanwhile, the company’s top-of-the-line V3400M model (photo, left) puts 4,000 lumens on the screen and has an 11.25- by 11.25-inch stage as well as a way to change the lamp without opening the case. It costs $370.
While these projectors can't put a laptop's output on the classroom's big screen, the teacher can write directly on the lighted stage with a marker, making it easier to tear apart a sentence, sketch a map of revolutionary America or explain the different triangles. The best part is that they're cheaper to operate. For instance, replacement lamps for these projectors cost about $10, not a couple hundred.
Short throw projectors are good for reducing teacher shadows on the screen but haven’t always been the brightest bulbs in the school. That is, until NEC’s UM 351W and 361X projectors. While the UM 351W ($1,369) displays wide-XGA resolution and puts 3,600 lumens on screen, the XGA-based UM361X ($1,149) puts out 3,500 lumens. Either way, it’s enough to light up just about any classroom. Both have HDMI ports that use the MHL spec for projecting the contetns of a phone or tablet and a 20-watt speaker that can be used with a microphone so that everyone can hear. With NEC’s NP03Wi interactive whiteboard kit, they can use pens for board work.
Flexibility and strength are the watchwords for yoga as they are for Lenovo’s second-generation Yoga convertible tablets. The Yoga Tablet 2 uses Android 4.4 software and is powered by a quad-core Atom Z3745 processor that runs at between 1.3- and 1.9GHz, 2GB of RAM and 32GB of solid state storage. Its 13-inch screen is about as detailed as they get these days with the ability to show 2,560 by 1,440 resolution. It has Bluetooth, 802.11ac WiFi and can be a standalone tablet, a traditional notebook or a presentation machine, yet weighs 2.1-pounds.
It may be bigger and heavier than other tablets, but the Yoga has a secret for teachers: in the thick cylindrical hinge, the Yoga 2 Pro has a micro projector. It can create up to a 50-inch image in wide-VGA resolution, but is rated at only 50 lumens, so the lights need to be off. It costs $500.